Wednesday, March 23, 2022

Picture Book Review: I'll Go and Come Back by Rajani LaRocca, illustrated by Sara Palacios (3/29/2022)


Quick Booktalk 

Jyoti, who lives in America, travels to visit her grandmother in India. When the visit ends, it's hard to say goodbye, so her grandmother teaches her the words that Tamil-speaking people use instead of goodbye, which translate as "I'll go and come back." 


About the Illustrations 

The pictures mostly depict Jyoti and her grandmother against a white background. Only a couple of scenes - in the airport, and on the street in India - take up a full spread. It would have been nice to see more of the differences between Jyoti's home and her grandmother's turn up in the pictures. There is a warmth and cheerfulness to each of the figures in the pictures that really highlight the loving relationship between grandmother and granddaughter. Their connection to each other is something all readers can relate to, and it helps give this story set within a specific culture universal appeal as well. 


Story Time Possibilities

The obvious story time theme for this book would be grandparents, but it would also work for things like travel, "around the world," India, Mother's Day, and/or a hello and goodbye theme. Some of the pictures are a bit tiny and might be hard to see, but for most average-sized story time audiences they should be fine.


Readers Advisory

Sara Palacios also illustrated My Day with the Panye by Tami Charles and A Song of Frutas by Margarita Engle, and it would be fun to read these titles together and discuss the different cultures depicted. I think it would also pair nicely with I Really Want to See You Grandma by Taro Gomi. 


Disclosure

I received a finished review copy of I'll Go and Come Back from Candlewick Press in exchange for an honest review. 

Picture Book Review: Slug in Love by Rachel Bright, illustrated by Nadia Shireen (12/14/2021)


Quick Booktalk

Doug the slug has a hard time finding someone to hug him. 


About the Illustrations 

The illustrations really carry this book. All the humor, color, and personality this book has to offer are found in the pictures and really nowhere else. Brightly colored blobs and geometric shapes against a white background form the bodies of Doug and the other characters he meets, as well as flowers, grass, and other bits of nature that serve as the setting. 


Story Time Possiblities

The clunky rhyming in this book will keep it out of my story times. There is so much rhyme for rhyme's sake - Doug, hug, slug, snug,  bug - and yet the author also rhymes all of these words with "love." It feels sloppy and uncomfortable to read aloud. 


Readers Advisory

Overall, this book just gave me a weird vibe. Kids don't generally relate to stories about falling in love, or about the loneliness of not being able to find someone to love, so the subject matter feels like a weird choice. The ending also feels very tacked on and unsatisfying. 


Disclosure 

I received a finished review copy of Slug in Love from Paula Wiseman Books in exchange for an honest review.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...