Quick Booktalk
This introduction to math for young readers explains part/whole relationships, addition, and fractions using examples from real life and bright, colorful illustrations.
About the Illustrations
The pages of this book are very busy, and it's hard to know where to look. Because the text is a bit of a hodgepodge, the illustrations are similarly random, and it's not easy to tell at a glance what is being expressed by each picture. The yellow borders where tiny supplemental text is printed are distracting and their color, in particular, makes it difficult to focus on either the tiny text or the main part of each page.
Story Time Possibilities
I think this is strictly a lap book because it's going to require quite a bit of extra context from an adult to make sense to the kids who are at this level mathematically. I actually think that my kids who have mastered the concepts the book covers would like it, but it would be totally overwhelming to a new learner. From a practical standpoint, the main text is too thin on its own, but the supplemental text on each page is too hard to see, making it sort of impossible to read it aloud while also showing the pictures to an audience.
Readers Advisory
For a reluctant math student, this book is going to be overwhelming and confusing. For kids who naturally love math, it may be fun to look at, but it's still not enough on its own to teach the concepts it sets out to teach. The cover is appealing, but inside, it's too much of a muddle for me.
Disclosure
I received a finished copy of We Are One from Candlewick Press in exchange for an honest review.
No comments :
Post a Comment